Twitter accounts for our guests:
Michelle Tobin > https://twitter.com/CorkSeashell
Rich Mifsud > https://twitter.com/Once_in_the_job
Padraig Kelly > https://twitter.com/the2ndRow
Twitter account for our guests:
Michelle Tobin > https://twitter.com/CorkSeashell
Keego > https://twitter.com/keegolaughs_irl
Cian O’Muilleoir > https://twitter.com/RugbyKino
Leinster Rugby’s dedication to Hazel Brown RIP > https://www.leinsterrugby.ie/hazel-brown-rip/
Twitter account for this week’s guest:
https://twitter.com/CorkSeashell
HarpinOnRugby on social media…
TWITTER > https://twitter.com/HarpinOnRugby
FACEBOOK > https://www.facebook.com/HarpinOnRugby
INSTAGRAM > https://www.instagram.com/harpinonrugby/
Twitter accounts for this week’s guests:
Michelle Tobin > https://twitter.com/CorkSeashell
Padraig Kelly > https://twitter.com/the2ndRow
David Topping > https://twitter.com/davethewingnut
Twitter accounts for this week’s guests:
Michelle Tobin > https://twitter.com/CorkSeashell
Ian Frizzell > https://twitter.com/rava_ian
Follow Michelle on Twitter > https://twitter.com/CorkSeashell
Follow Ian on Twitter > https://twitter.com/rava_ian
Follow Stephen on Twitter > https://twitter.com/MasterOfNonePod
Subscribe to Master Of None Podcast > anchor.fm/stephen-murphy8
It’s well known that I have two passions, rugby and musical theatre. Every time I see another article or tweet about the latest issues for the Lions Tour I hear Colm Wilkinson’s voice singing “Bring them home, bring them HOME” – les miserables indeed!
My love for the Lions began with the incredible 1997 tour of South Africa. I watched all of those games over and over again, I owned all of the “Living with the Lions” videos – remember VHS? It was quite traumatic when I had to consign those to the bin, over a decade after I last had a working VHS player. On one of the flights to NZ in 2017, I was overawed to hear that one of our group had actually been on that 1997 tour – I’m not sure he could believe my excitement.
And so, the next Lions tour after #mylionsadventure in New Zealand in 2017, South Africa 2021 was something I looked forward to since we landed back in Dublin from NZ. And then, you know, Covid.
If you’ve listened to my podcasts on here you’ll know that I, like many others, was frustrated with the lack of regard Lions Officials seemed to have for the thousands of supporters who had invested five figure sums in plans to go on the tour. I was lucky, Rugby Travel Ireland kept us in the loop as much as they could and as often as they could. Several months ago, I knew I wasn’t going to South Africa, a relief to have closure at last. But the rugby was going ahead??
Randomly, I have a degree in immunology, but you didn’t need to be a scientist to see that the plans to go to South Africa and play the planned eight matches was not the sensible option. There had been talk of relocating the games, New Zealand, Australia, Dubai were all mentioned as was a proposal to play the games across Britain and Ireland. All were ruled out, or vetoed, for various reasons but the bottom line really is the bottom line, it’s all about the money.
And so the squad and management team boarded flights to South Africa, aware that this was to be a tour unlike any other. We all saw the images of temperatures being taken at the SA hotel, and all the luggage being disinfected, window dressing it turns out. Wednesday brought the revelation that some of the hotel staff at the hotel when the Lions first arrived had tested positive for Covid, and that it suspected that that’s how there were positive Covid tests in the Lions camp. You couldn’t make this up!
The Lions Tour Bio-Bubble rulebook is available for all to see. It clearly states that only staff residing in the bio-bubble may access team areas. Yet the positive tests are being attributed to hotel staff?
The other big revelation on Wednesday night (I’ll get to the rugby, I promise!) was that “nearly all/the vast majority” of the Lions have been double jabbed. This just blows my mind. NOT ALL of the Lions are fully vaccinated. Yes the issue could be late call ups but I simply don’t understand how they couldn’t have been fully vaccinated before departure. We don’t need to know who but we do need to know why. Why was being fully vaccinated not a condition of boarding that plane?
And so to Wednesday’s game. Positive tests in the Lions camp? Who? How? What happens now? Well what happened as we know was the game was played, requiring some players to play their third game in less than two weeks, a bench with only one back (where was Peter O’Mahony when we needed him!), and a set of jerseys that ended up being as much of a talking point as the rugby. The result was never in doubt, the best available players from the home nations v a team stripped of their internationals. Though the Cell C Sharks played some great rugby at times, and their try was a thing of beauty, they were never going to challenge. But it seems they’re up for a second bite of the cherry this weekend – there are not enough rolleye emojis in existence to give my reaction to this news. It’s rugby for money’s sake alone. Money, money, money.
The broadcasters and sponsors are already down a fixture this weekend with the Springboks v Georgia being called off relatively early this week. At that stage we only knew of the many cases in the Springbok side, so a slightly tasty game v Georgia looked like a possibility given Bulls hadn’t even made it into their bio-bubble for our original Saturday game, but positives in the Georgia camp nixed that idea. So then there was a major push to find opposition for the Lions for this weekend, God forbid we would be down two big fixtures this weekend. And so we face the Sharks again (pending negative tests), I’m guessing I’m not alone in being “unenthusiastic” about this fixture, and indeed the tour.
I tweeted earlier this week that fears for the Lions brand had prevented the tour cycle being pushed back a full four years, but the damage that may have done is nothing compared to the damage being done to the brand with what’s going on. I stand by that assertion. I know a lot of passionate Lions supporters who are disappointed, disillusioned, disenchanted. I’m one of those. Anyone who read my 12 blog posts from New Zealand in 2017 will know how passionate and excited I was, and how much I loved every minute of that tour and looked forward to this one, until the writing was on the wall, this tour was going to be like no other, and not in a good way.
On the “Harp Off” podcast last week, Keego made a great point (no not the red underpants one!) about what happens if a Lions player breaks a bone, or gets sick and needs to go to hospital. We’ve seen the news reports about the chaos in South African hospitals, clearly unable to cope with the massive surge of Covid cases. Even the thought that one of the Lions players might have to go into such environments terrifies me. Why are ok with that possibility? Why are we ok that the Springboks jumped the queue for vaccination so that they could play these games, just 0.8% of the population of South Africa is fully vaccinated. Is our entertainment, our sport, so important?
As the days go by I’m becoming more and more uneasy about this tour, one I wasn’t happy to see go ahead in the first place – it’s not a real Lions tour, the players are putting on the jersey, but they’re not getting the full Lions experience, the sea of red who’ve travelled from the other side of the world to support them, the magical buzz of a tour that combines rugby and enjoying the beautiful host countries. They get masks, a bio bubble, Covid tests, stress, and risk. Waiting another four years would not have been the end of the world, with an average age of 28.5 most of these players have time.
A number of pundits, former players and journalists have come out on the morality of the Lions tour going ahead. And I totally get it, I totally agree. Sadly an article in the Times (UK) last week nailed it “Money, not morality, will ensure that British & Irish Lions tour reaches the Tests against South Africa”. In black and white it laid out why the right thing comes secondary to the bottom line. And it breaks my heart, the Lions I love are about community, passion, and compassion, but it turns out it’s all about the money.
Regardless of what the article says, I don’t think we’ll get to the Tests, we shouldn’t. Finances aside, it’s in nobody’s best interest for this shambles of a “tour” to continue. Bring them home, please, bring them home.
Michelle Tobin (@CorkSeashell) : A passionate Munster, Ireland, Lions rugby supporter. Known to get up in the middle of the night to watch live rugby, she is also a big Auckland Blues fan - though not a natural supporter of teams in blue! Having written match day experience and contract posts for this blog, and her 12 Lions diary episodes in 2017, she finally started talking rugby on the HoR podcasts in 2020 and hasn't stopped! She is not sure she will ever get over CJ Stander's early retirement
Follow this week's panel on Twitter..
Michelle Tobin > https://twitter.com/CorkSeashell
Ian Frizzell > https://twitter.com/rava_ian
Mark Jackson > https://twitter.com/hoomanbear
Trivia question for you, no googling allowed….which two players starting at the RDS on Saturday wore the same starting jerseys at Thomond Park back in May 2011? Scroll to the end for the answer.
And those memories of Munster’s last major trophy success will be one of many things spurring them one from minute 1 to 80...but I let one of their biggest fans Michelle talk about the view from their end of the N7 in the interest of fairness, and also in the interest of my being allowed to be totally biased in my own preview!!! Check out the podcast in the player below or even better, why not subscribe for further episodes - we’ve an interesting one coming up looking at the anatomy of a citing commissioner's hearing.
Anyway, on Leinster - well it was always going to be about how the players were fed back into the team from the Six Nations, wasn’t it. To be honest I’m surprised to see this many actually playing especially with knockout European rugby a week later, but I have definitely no complaints as it gives what is a major final in its own right the respect it deserves.
The challenge for Leo & co was always going to be find the balance between rewarding those who helped get us to this final while still adding in all the test talent, and for the most part they have managed it. Luke McGrath is most certainly a worthy captain for the day and responded to exclusion from test level in exactly the right way with a string of fine performances.
I also didn’t bat an eyelid when I saw Rory O’Loughlin tapped to fill Garry Ringrose’s role at 13. We could have gone many different ways with this selection, like copying what Ireland did against England and move Robbie to outside and put in a playmaker at 12 but knowing we’d be up against de Allende & Farrell it was better to go with the strength and there promises to be quite the battle in the centre.
Then there’s Dave Kearney. In the form of his life and scoring tries for fun...there may not be too many chances for him this time but if they come there’s no better man to make the most of them.
Of course there have to be a good few from the 16-match regular season that are unlucky to miss out, like Scott Penny who also found the try line a lot, as well Michael Bent who has become a real Mr Dependable.
There's a middle category of sorts between the Pro14 and test squads which of course features Rhys Ruddock, and the “Leinster Back Row One-Arm Bandit” has thrown up quite a trio this week as he is joined by the same 7 and 8 that just helped demolish the English.
It’s really difficult to find any technical aspect of the game where one team will have the edge in this one. Scrum, lineouts (btw special congrats to Big Dev for breaking the record number of Leinster appearances), restart exits, ball carrying, even discipline all fall under that old cliché of “fine margins”. What could decide it is that other worn-out saying - “passion”.
We know Leinster have been able to build their success on an almost religious adherence to not only specific tactics, but also an insistence on high standards when it comes to execution. Since we know that Munster have so much to play for besides the actual rivalry, we need to be sure that we’re ready to meet them head on in those opening minutes because if we’re not careful they could knock us off our game.
But if, as is very likely, these two great sides manage to cancel each other out for the opening hour or so, then we must turn to the benches and what a set of names we find there. Obviously the name Sexton stands out but there’s also Furlong, Baird and a certain Mr Lowe who might feel he wants to make a statement.
Also as I say myself in the podcast, in a tight cup rugby match like this one you can’t forget the potential influence of the officials, especially when you’re bound to have two teams which are bound to remain high in the tackle which can always lead to trouble.
Overall my view when it comes to a prediction is that the 6 point Leinster spread offered by the bookies is a shade high. Munster have a host of match winners and while it’s very possible that either team can pull away if given the opportunity, the chances are that this will stay tighter than a camel’s arse in a sandstorm, as the saying goes (if that is a saying?).
But as much as pretty much everyone outside the 12 counties and probably outside the four provinces as well will be cheering for a Munster win, how could I do anything but back the boys in blue to lift title number 8, if only by 3-5 points.
So here’s to a classic final to live up to the billing, to the match being decided by rugby talent not referee sanction and also, of course, to no injuries for either side ahead of Europe the following weekend.
As always follow me on Twitter throughout the match and once the full time whistle blows head over to the Facebook page to leave your thoughts. JLP
